![]() ![]() Literally, it means 'action follows being. To read this article in its entirety, please download the free PDF or buy this issue. Agere sequitur esse - is the fundamental axiom or principle on which Natural law rests. We will evaluate Austriaco’s claim of certitude regarding the product generated by ANT-OAR, and his criticism of the “Response to the Joint Statement,” relative to his reading of this Thomistic axiom which, by his own express acknowledgment, undergirds both the certitude and the criticism. This is an argument grounded in the Aristotelian- Thomistic axiom, agere sequitur esse” (706). “This is not an argument derived from a flawed mechanistic philosophy. themselves in the proper way for their existence (agere sequitur esse). In other words, radical disorganization (absence of coordinated interaction of parts) in an OAR-generated entity leads reasonably and with certitude to the conclusion that this entity is not and was not in its original constitution an embryo, but only a tumor. Translations in context of sequitur in English-Polish from Reverso Context. Again, agere sequitur esse” (706 emphasis added). Austriaco invokes this axiom as the foundation for the central claim of the OAR proposal: “we can reasonably and with certitude conclude that an OAR-generated entity that becomes a tumor is ontologically different from an embryo, because its different organization and behavior shows that it has a different nature. Furthermore, agree sequitur esse is the traditional statement of the Metaphysical and Moral Principle that grounds a person's moral duties and the possibilities in one's very being. Literally, it means 'action follows being.' In other words, by knowing the nature of something is (what something is), we can know something about how it should act (its ethics). Thomas von Aquin schrieb in seiner Summa contra gentiles vom agere sequitur ad esse in actu (das Tätigsein folgt auf das Wirklichsein) 1. An examination of Austriaco’s criticism will help clarify further the fundamental question raised by ANT-OAR: what properly defines an organism (embryo), and by what criteria do we distinguish an organism from a non-organism? Of crucial significance here is the Aristotelian-Thomistic axiom, agere sequitur esse, and indeed the Aristotelian-Thomistic notion of substance (hylomorphism). Agere sequitur esse - is the fundamental axiom or principle on which Natural law rests. das Handeln folgt dem Sein) bezeichnet ein, insbesondere durch von Thomas von Aquin bekannt gewordenes, Prinzip im scholastischen Denken. Christian Brugger in the present number of Communio. "Austriaco defines being not by what it is, but by what is its first (ontological) effect."įather Nicanor Austriaco concludes his article, “Are Teratomas Embryos or Non-Embryos? A Criterion for Oocyte-Assisted Reprogramming,” 1 with a strong criticism of “A Response to the Joint Statement, ‘Production of Pluripotent Stem Cells by Oocyte Assisted Reprogramming’” 2 for reasons similar to those advanced by E. That is why CMUKs motto is agere sequitur esse. ![]() God and Reason / Biotechnology & Morality, Part V Agere sequitur esse: What Does It Mean? A Reply to Father Austriaco Our primary vocation is towards fatherhood, to become and to act like fathers, in whatever we are called to do.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |